Search doesn't work the way it did five years ago, and the numbers make it hard to argue otherwise. More than two-thirds of Google searches now end without a single click. AI tools like ChatGPT and Claude send fewer than one in a thousand visitors out to the open web. Social platforms hold onto 98 or 99 out of every 100 people who start a session there. Whatever we thought "search" meant, it has quietly become something else: an activity that happens everywhere, on every platform, most of the time without ever sending anyone to a website.
We recently talked with Rand Fishkin, co-founder of the audience research tool SparkToro, about what this shift actually means for marketers. His take is blunt: the old playbook isn't just declining, it's over. He compared it to optimizing for HotBot and Lycos in 2010. “The time has passed, my friend,” he said. “We need to move on and recognize that the instant answer, the zero click era is formally here.”
Zero-Click Is Everywhere
In 2024, 58% of Google searches ended without a click. According to research Rand’s team completed with Similarweb, that number is now above 67%, the fastest two-year jump in the twelve years his team has been tracking it. The pattern holds well beyond Google:
- AI tools send fewer than 1 in 1,000 visits back out to the open web.
- Social platforms (Instagram, LinkedIn, Reddit, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook) keep 98 to 99 out of every 100 users inside the app.
- Instant answers now show up directly inside searches on Instagram and TikTok, not just Google.
The term for this, coined by a UK-based marketer named Ashley, is search everywhere optimization. As Rand put it, "search is way bigger" than Google, Bing, or DuckDuckGo. It happens on YouTube, on Reddit, inside every social app and every e-commerce site. Treating SEO as a Google-only discipline is already behind the curve.
Attribution Was Always an Illusion
Here's the harder pill to swallow: even before the zero-click era, precise attribution was mostly a story we told ourselves. Rand compared today's marketing landscape to the ad agencies of the 1960s, who never pretended to trace a single sale back to a single billboard. They measured lift in same-store sales across a region instead. "No one even tried" individual-level attribution, he said, because it was obviously unrealistic at scale.
For a strange stretch of about fifteen years, roughly 2005 to 2020, that changed. Dashboards could show a clean path: a LinkedIn visit led to content consumption, which led to an email signup, which led to a conversion. It felt like real measurement. But that window is closing fast. LinkedIn now hides referral data on a large share of organic visits. People increasingly consume content without ever leaving the platform. Posting a link limits your reach; skipping the link protects your reach but erases your attribution trail entirely.
The result, in Rand's words, is that "we still haven't evolved past" the belief that everything can and should be attributed. That belief has quietly pushed budgets in one direction.
Paid Gets the Credit. Organic Does the Work.
When you buy an ad on LinkedIn, Google, Meta, Reddit, or TikTok, you get a click, and with it, clean attribution that looks great in a dashboard. Organic influence, meanwhile, often shows up nowhere. Rand argues this asymmetry, not actual performance, is why paid budgets have exploded: “Organic might be 10 times, 100 times the influence. Paid is always going to get the credit.”
He estimates the real split in influence is still roughly 80/20 in favor of organic. But because paid is measurable and organic often isn't, the incentive structure inside most companies rewards the channel that looks good in a report over the channel that's actually doing the work.
Big platforms have little reason to correct this. As Rand noted, Google, Meta, and other major players benefit when marketers believe attribution still functions cleanly, because that belief keeps budgets flowing toward channels that show up as "converting traffic," which tends to mean paid.
Short-Form Video Is the New Superpower
If precise attribution is gone, what should marketers actually invest their energy in? Rand's answer is direct: short-form video. "Nothing else captures attention like short form video," he said, "and this is regardless of platform." YouTube Shorts, TikTok, Instagram, a well-placed video on the right subreddit, even short video on LinkedIn all perform at a level nothing else matches right now.
He frames this as a meaningfully more creative discipline than traditional SEO ever was. Optimizing a snippet for a Google ranking was mildly creative, but in his words, a “pretty technical process.” Short-form video is “much more human in a lot of ways.” Paxton Gray added that it requires a much deeper understanding of human psychology, persuasion, hooks, and attention. The iteration cycle is faster than anything else in marketing before it. You can release multiple shorts a day, then learn and iterate quickly.
Distribution Beats Optimization: What Reddit Taught Us
One of the more counterintuitive lessons from our conversation was about Reddit. Rand has started posting his own research charts directly into relevant subreddits, and the results surprised even him. A piece of zero-click search research that engaged roughly 100,000 people on LinkedIn and a few thousand on the company blog pulled in more than a million impressions on Reddit.
Almost nobody clicks through. "It's AI levels of click-through rate," he said, "like one in a thousand people." But that's not really the point. Reddit doesn't drive direct signups. It drives visibility among journalists and other people who shape opinion, and that secondhand coverage lifts brand search volume, AI visibility, and general awareness in ways a direct click never could.
The framework underneath this: every business has two audiences, the customers who will eventually buy, and the influencers who shape what those customers believe. Reddit, for him, is squarely an influencer channel. He reaches customers on LinkedIn, Threads, Twitter, the blog, the email newsletter, and podcasts.
Brand Recognition Is the Long-Term Play
The clearest example of where all this points came from Paxton. In a recent competitive analysis for an active wearables company, one brand stood out for following none of the AI visibility best practices and still leading by a wide margin: Garmin. “They’ve got the best watch. They’ve got the best brand,” he said. He’d argue Garmin could grow its market share even more by optimizing, but the brand is doing the majority of the work.
The same logic is behind Rand’s bet on Alert Mouse, his tool for tracking brand mentions. He believes tracking where your brand shows up in media and creator sources will be hugely important to how you show up in LLMs long term, because models look for the “co-occurrence of brand plus terms.” Short-term tricks may still work for a few months, the same way spammy links and stuffed anchor text once worked for Google. But a YouTube strategy, a LinkedIn strategy, Reddit participation, and content marketing will move the needle on AI visibility “six months, 12 months, 18 months, and 10 years from now.”
The hardest part isn't understanding any of this. It's convincing the people who control budget to act on it. As Rand put it, it's oddly easy to get executives to throw money at the newest AI visibility trend, and strangely difficult to get the same budget approved for a YouTube strategy or a long-term content program, even when the second option is very likely to matter more.
Resources
Pre-order Rand’s new book, Zero Click Marketing: https://zeroclickmarketing.co/book
Connect with Rand on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/randfishkin
Connect with Paxton on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/paxtongray/
Looking for an agency that'll be worth the investment? 97th Floor creates custom, audience-first campaigns that drive pipeline and conversions. Get started here: https://97staging.com/lets-talk/.
About Rand Fishkin
Rand Fishkin is CEO and cofounder of three companies: SparkToro, makers of fine audience research software, pun-filled Google Alerts alternative Alertmouse, and indie game developer Snackbar Studio.
He’s the co-author (with Amanda Natividad) of the upcoming Zero Click Marketing and 2018’s Lost and Founder. When Rand’s not working, he’s usually traveling with or cooking a fancy meal for the love of his life, bestselling author Geraldine DeRuiter.
