Google promises better results with just one click—“Apply All Recommendations.” But what if those recommendations aren’t actually in your best interest? At 97th Floor, we’ve seen firsthand how blindly following Google's automated suggestions can drain budgets and derail strategy. So we put it to the test. In a head-to-head experiment, we pitted Google’s recommended setup against our tailored, expert-built campaigns. The results were eye-opening—and could change the way you manage your ad spend.
We tested campaigns with three of our clients to compare the effectiveness of Google’s automated recommendations with the hands-on approach taken by our experienced advertising team at 97th Floor. Each campaign was structured to align with specific goals, but the key difference was in how they were managed:
| 97th Floor | ||
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Select one | Select one |
| Conversion actions | Auto-select | Manually select |
| Campaign type | Search | Search |
| How you reach goals | Visit website | Visit website |
| Bidding | Start with conversions | Start with clicks |
| Max CPC limit | Don’t start with one | Start with one depending on client; not too restrictive (e.g., under $10) |
| Networks | Allow Search partners and Google Display Network | Turn Google Display Network off; test Search partners if... |
| Location | Set a location as presence or interest | Set a location as presence only |
| Audience Segments | Observational targeting | Observational targeting |
| Broad match | On | Off |
| Automatically created assets | On | Off |
| Ad rotation | Optimize for best performance | Optimize for best performance |
| Ad schedule | None | Add if needed |
| Campaign creation | Go through Google's process | Go through 97th Floor's process |
| Ad copy | Use Google's suggestions | Written by expert content marketer |
| Budget | Equal budget | Equal budget |
| Optimizations | Turn on auto apply recommendations for this campaign | Optimize manually |
Here are the settings we kept the same between the control and test group. These are Google’s recommendations that we agree with.
| 97th Floor | ||
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Select one | Select one |
| Campaign type | Search | Search |
| How you reach goals | Visit website | Visit website |
| Audience Segments | Observational targeting | Observational targeting |
| Ad rotation | Optimize for best performance | Optimize for best performance |
| Budget | Equal budget | Equal budget |
When you feed a smart bidding system bad signals, you get bad results. We focus on signal quality to guide the algorithm toward actual business growth — not just form fills or button clicks that look good on paper.
| 97th Floor | ||
|---|---|---|
| Conversion actions | Auto-select | Manually select |
Smart bidding needs data to perform well. Jumping straight to "Maximize Conversions" without historical data is like trying to sprint before you've learned to walk. Our approach allows us to build a strong foundation — minimizing waste while setting the campaigns up for smarter automation later.
Without a CPC cap, Google can overspend on low-quality traffic. We applied reasonable limits to protect budget efficiency.
| 97th Floor | ||
|---|---|---|
| Bidding | Start with conversions | Start with clicks |
| Max CPC limit | Don’t start with one | Start with one depending on client; not too restrictive (e.g., under $10) |
The Display Network may offer more impressions, but not always better ones. Especially early on, we want every click to count — and that means keeping the focus tight on search intent, not expanding blindly into display.
Advertising to someone thinking about your market is not the same as advertising to someone in your market. Having your location set as presence or interest allows Google to waste your dollars on the wrong users.
Google's default runs ads 24/7. We customized schedules to align with peak engagement and business hours when necessary.
| 97th Floor | ||
|---|---|---|
| Networks | Allow Search partners and Google Display Network | Turn Google Display Network off; test Search partners if... |
| Location | Set a location as presence or interest | Set a location as presence only |
| Ad schedule | None | Add if needed |
Broad match can open the floodgates — sometimes usefully, sometimes recklessly. We prefer a controlled expansion. Typically, we prioritize stricter match types, like phrase or exact. We use broad match strategically, mostly on longer tailed terms since the intent is more spelled out. It’s important to test broader match types strategically—you don’t want to waste ad spend but you do want to take into account that 15% of searches every day are new. People could be in the market for your product or solution but type it in differently than your keywords. Broad match keywords are a good way to mine for new keyword ideas.
| 97th Floor | ||
|---|---|---|
| Broad match | On | Off |
Auto-generated ads often sound robotic and generic, or can state things that are outright wrong. We believe brand voice is too important to automate away — especially when you have just seconds to grab a user’s attention and build trust.
| 97th Floor | ||
|---|---|---|
| Automatically created assets | On | Off |
In every case, the campaigns managed by 97th Floor outperformed those set up using Google’s automated recommendations. Here's a breakdown of the results:
The data speaks for itself—relying solely on Google’s recommendations can leave performance on the table. While Google’s automation offers convenience, it lacks the precision and strategic insight required to maximize advertising budgets effectively. 97th Floor’s campaigns delivered better results, proving that expertise and human intervention are essential for optimal ad performance.
If you're relying entirely on Google’s automation, you could be spending more without seeing the results you deserve. At 97th Floor, we offer expert campaign management that outperforms Google’s one-size-fits-all approach. Contact us today to see how a professionally managed campaign can transform your advertising results.
See how a professionally-managed campaign can transform your advertising results.
